Is religion necessary for morality many people think it is outrageous, or even blasphemous, to deny that morality is of divine origin either some divine being crafted our moral sense during the period of creation or we picked it up from the teachings of organized religion both views see the same. If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice simply select your manager software from the list below and click on download. That is why we need revelation the bible, which contains god’s revealed moral will in his law and commandments, is his revelation to his people as such, the bible becomes our source of morality because the bible is the very word of god in written form (2 timothy 3:16 2 peter 1:21) why should the bible be our source for morality find. This feature is not available right now please try again later.
Religion, which includes the repudiation of any attempt to ground morality upon a religious foundation, has been so overwhelmingly successful since the enlightenment that philosophers today need only undertake “mopping. Does morality need religion although religion plays a large role in the shaping of an individual, there are other factors that come from the individual’s native morals that are even stronger than religion which leads the. Religion is not necessary at all in determining basic right from wrong right and wrong do not need to be determined by religions religion often makes natural and harmless behaviors such as dancing and singing into something sinful, while at the same time endorsing killing in wars. Does ethics require religion do we need god to be good by jeremy adam smith december 1, 2007 moral monkeys by jeremy adam smith february 5, 2007 empathy vs logic vs morality by jeremy adam smith march 22, 2007 the science of spirituality: a review of fingerprints of god by cjay roughgarden august 25, 2009.
George washington once warned that it is folly to suppose that “morality can be maintained without religion” studies repeatedly have shown this statement to be true author david myers penned an essay titled “godliness and goodliness,” which appeared in the magazine sightings (4/11/01. Being a moral agent means considering that other beings have moral standing, and exercising morality is making decisions about what should be done and what should not be done but, if you are following a religion's prescriptive rules about what to do and what not to do, you are in fact not acting morally at all. Religious morality: morality which is based on aspects of religion such as fear of god or the desire to do god's will for example: god commands that i help others in need because it is his will, so i must help others. Does morality need religion ms mcbain hsb 4m0 february 29, 2012 to many individuals, morality and religion are two related but distinct ideas to be specific, morality consists of principles set by societal norms concerning the distinction between right and wrong and good and bad behaviour among persons alternatively, religion involves the. We need religion for morality pros cons in order to go from is to ought, one must introduce something from outside the realm of the is if people are only the physical and merely result from biological and chemical reactions, there is no self-determination.
Does morality depend on religion april 30, 2015 ethics - religion, philosophy of religion john messerly why should i be moral one answer is that if we are moral, the gods will reward us and if not, the gods will punish us. Is morality linked to religion thomas ash many people believe that morality and religion are fundamentally linked they may see this as an argument for god's existence (if atheism's true, there can be no moral facts moral facts exist therefore god does too), but in this essay i shall evaluate it simply as a factual claim. In popular thinking, morality and religion are inseparable: people commonly believe that morality can be understood only in the context of religion so because the clergymen are the spokesmen for religion, it is assumed that they must be spokesmen for morality as well. If god does not exist, everything is permitted - this is the belief of ivan karamazov, a fictional character from fyodor dostoevsky's novel the brothers karamazov, and is similarly held by people who conventionally encounter the issue of morality.
What we do not want is to selectively choose a limited list of moral behaviors and defend the list as though it is a supreme command or the only desirable behaviors for judging morality. Morality and religion is the relationship between religious views and morals many religions have value frameworks regarding personal behavior meant to guide adherents in determining between right and wrong. Secular morality and religious morality inadvertently influenced one another - even in matters of outwardly secular morality, religion plays such a hegemonic role that, in many instances, secular morality is inadvertently influenced by religious morality. You can live without the need of soul based religion and be ethical and moral for those of us that do not believe in organized religion there are alternatives.
From the beginning of the abrahamic faiths and of greek philosophy, religion and morality have been closely intertwined this is true whether we go back within greek philosophy or within christianity and judaism and islam who held not only that morality did not need religion, but that religion, and especially christianity, was its major. Many assume that religion and morality have a necessary connection, but the basis of morality is essentially just the golden rule: do not do unto others what you would not like to be done unto you humans are intelligent individuals and we do not need religion to tell us what makes people happy or what makes people suffer.
So, in a way, morality does depend on religion, but only the religion as a social group the religion as a belief in a god doesn't make someone moral i would argue the opposite, a sense of morality must exist for a religion to function. The descriptive sense of “morality”, which allows for the view that morality is based on religion in this way, picks out codes of conduct that are often in significant conflict with all normative accounts of morality. You don't need religion to have morals, but without religion there is no objective basis for your moral system if your morals are based on the good of society, even hitler and stalin felt they were serving the good of society in their murderous genocides, as were the butchers in rwanda and their genocidal mayhem.